Syno Notatus or Nummifer?
- gibbo
- Posts: 50
- Joined: 01 Jan 2003, 16:42
- Location 1: Derbyshire, UK
- Interests: Fishkeeping, Photography, Cinema, Crime Literature
Syno Notatus or Nummifer?
A bit of a dilemma... I got three Syno's (labelled as Clown Syno's, which as you all know is Syno Decorus) knowing that they would be Notatus. I recently got the Baensch atlas series and my fish, according to that book, is Syno Nummifer (vol 2, p545). I Looked up Nummifer at Planet Catfish and it looks totally different. According to Baensch, Nummifer and Notatus are very similar and my fish are identical to the books Photograph. The Notatus that I have seen have very distinctive, round spots. My fish have softer, more 'blurred' spots and more 'oval' eyes. I know it sounds a bit trivial but I would really love to positively ID the fish. Are they both widely available in UK ( I'm under the impression that the Notatus are)?
Pictures: [img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-1-1 ... &ro=0&co=0
[/img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-2-1 ... &ro=0&co=1
[img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-3-1 ... &ro=0&co=2
[/img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-4-1 ... &ro=0&co=3
The third picture is a detail of the spots if it helps.
Pictures: [img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-1-1 ... &ro=0&co=0
[/img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-2-1 ... &ro=0&co=1
[img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-3-1 ... &ro=0&co=2
[/img]http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-4-1 ... &ro=0&co=3
The third picture is a detail of the spots if it helps.
- gibbo
- Posts: 50
- Joined: 01 Jan 2003, 16:42
- Location 1: Derbyshire, UK
- Interests: Fishkeeping, Photography, Cinema, Crime Literature
Sorry, pics didn't work.... I'll try again!
Hopefully this works
http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-2-1 ... &ro=0&co=1
http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-3-1 ... &ro=0&co=2
http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-4-1 ... &ro=0&co=3
Couldn't get first pic to register!!
Hopefully this works
http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-2-1 ... &ro=0&co=1
http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-3-1 ... &ro=0&co=2
http://photo.starblvd.net/gibbo/1-1-4-1 ... &ro=0&co=3
Couldn't get first pic to register!!
- clothahump
- Posts: 441
- Joined: 30 Dec 2002, 17:24
- Location 1: Deepest Darkest Dorset UK
- Contact:
- Dinyar
- Posts: 1286
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 00:34
- My articles: 3
- My images: 229
- My catfish: 10
- My cats species list: 3 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 94
- Location 1: New York, NY, USA
- Interests: Mochokidae, Claroteidae, Bagridae, Malepteruridae, Chacidae, Heteropneustidae, Clariidae, Sisoridae, Loricariiadae
Hard to tell based on the rear view photos, but looks like 2-spot notatus. S. notatus and S. nummifer look very similar and have more or less the same geographical distribution. S. nummifer has a somewhat deeper body. In my limited experience with these two fish, S. notatus is more common in the trade.
Post a head shot or side view of the fish and we can revisit the ID.
Post a head shot or side view of the fish and we can revisit the ID.
- smilingSyno
- Posts: 36
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 15:24
- Location 1: Florida, USA
- Interests: Synodontis, Corydoras, Hoplos, Plecos etc.
- Contact:
I'm wondering if that S. nummifer you are talking about is the same fish that my Dr. Axelrod's Atlas has as S. ocellifer?
A good way to tell the two apart is that S. nonatus has clear fins while S. ocellifer has spotted fins. As far as I can see from your pictures your fish has spots on his tail and fins so I would say he is a S. ocellifer. Also his shape and spots look exactly like the photo of S. ocellifer I have in my book.
Dr. Axelrod's Atlas doesn't have a S. nummifer so I guess it's the same fish and they call it S. ocellifer for whatever reason. But then again I just looked the two up in the Catfish Library and they look very different in the pictures there. So I don't know about S. nummifer and if it's the same, but I believe you have a S. ocellifer.
This is what my book says about S. ocellifer: ph 7, H 10, temp 25 C, size 30 cm, required tank size 300 liters, bottom dweller, easy to keep, good beginner fish, likes live worms, dim light, plants, rocks and driftwood.
Hope that helps you. Do a search on S. ocellifer and see if you find any more pictures.
A good way to tell the two apart is that S. nonatus has clear fins while S. ocellifer has spotted fins. As far as I can see from your pictures your fish has spots on his tail and fins so I would say he is a S. ocellifer. Also his shape and spots look exactly like the photo of S. ocellifer I have in my book.
Dr. Axelrod's Atlas doesn't have a S. nummifer so I guess it's the same fish and they call it S. ocellifer for whatever reason. But then again I just looked the two up in the Catfish Library and they look very different in the pictures there. So I don't know about S. nummifer and if it's the same, but I believe you have a S. ocellifer.
This is what my book says about S. ocellifer: ph 7, H 10, temp 25 C, size 30 cm, required tank size 300 liters, bottom dweller, easy to keep, good beginner fish, likes live worms, dim light, plants, rocks and driftwood.
Hope that helps you. Do a search on S. ocellifer and see if you find any more pictures.
- smilingSyno
- Posts: 36
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 15:24
- Location 1: Florida, USA
- Interests: Synodontis, Corydoras, Hoplos, Plecos etc.
- Contact:
- Sid Guppy
- Posts: 757
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 15:36
- Location 1: Brabant, the Netherlands
- Interests: Catfish, Tanganyikan fish, Rock'n'roll, Fantasy
No; the fish is most likely a notatus, not an ocellifer (nice ocellifer btw in the last pic)
too bad the head cannot be seen; because that's were you can see if it's a nummifer or a notatus best; they got a different shape of head, and different shaped eyes, whiskers etc:
Nummifer's got a head like pleurops, contractus etc; big eyes, blunt head, very short, thin whiskers.
Notatus got a more 'regular' syno-head, with long upper whiskers and a more pointed head, and normal eyes. (except when juvenile, but the pic shows a fairly adult fish)
my money is on three spot notatus.
too bad the head cannot be seen; because that's were you can see if it's a nummifer or a notatus best; they got a different shape of head, and different shaped eyes, whiskers etc:
Nummifer's got a head like pleurops, contractus etc; big eyes, blunt head, very short, thin whiskers.
Notatus got a more 'regular' syno-head, with long upper whiskers and a more pointed head, and normal eyes. (except when juvenile, but the pic shows a fairly adult fish)
my money is on three spot notatus.
Plan B should not automatically be twice as much explosives as Plan A
Using Sands' Catfishes Of The World book as a reference I would say those are nummifer for 3 reasons. One of the best ways of IDing synos is the shape of the adipose fin. Notatus has a much smaller adipose.Numiffer has pattern on the caudal while notatus is clear. And lastly the term "clown syno" can actually refer to nummifer as well. When nummifer is small (2-3") it looks almost identical to decorus. The easiest way to tell the difference at that size is the number of bars on the caudal. Your 3 were probably smaller when the wholesaler got them and were misIDed at that point. Be happy- nummifer is rarer than the other 2.
Take care,
Tom
Take care,
Tom
- Silurus
- Posts: 12370
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 11:35
- I've donated: $12.00!
- My articles: 55
- My images: 884
- My catfish: 1
- My cats species list: 90 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 419
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Moderator Emeritus
Using Poll's revision of <i>Synodontis</i> as a rough guide</i>, I would say that those are <i>S. nummifer</i>. Tom is right, <i>S. nummifer</i> has a larger adipose fin. The other important distinguishing feature is the shape of the cleithral (humeral) process, which is much broader in <i>S. nummifer</i> than it is in <i>S. notatus</i>. The fish in the photos have a relatively large adipose fin, and a broad cleithral process, therefore <i>S. nummifer</i>.
Heok Hee
Heok Hee
Last edited by Silurus on 05 Jan 2003, 00:39, edited 2 times in total.
To add to the confusion-
The picture in Baensch's Vol. 2 is actually Synodontis congicus -a smaller(4'') Syno. The picture on planetcatfish is a very young nummifer. you can see the resemblance to decorus. Another difference is young nummifer have spotting on the head, decorus never do at any stage of their life.
Take care,
Tom
The picture in Baensch's Vol. 2 is actually Synodontis congicus -a smaller(4'') Syno. The picture on planetcatfish is a very young nummifer. you can see the resemblance to decorus. Another difference is young nummifer have spotting on the head, decorus never do at any stage of their life.
Take care,
Tom
- smilingSyno
- Posts: 36
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 15:24
- Location 1: Florida, USA
- Interests: Synodontis, Corydoras, Hoplos, Plecos etc.
- Contact:
Why not just make this topic a poll? But seriously, there seem to be many different opinions. Some more pictures would definitely help. I have a question too: Can anybody tell me if S. nummifer and S. ocellifer are two different names for the same species? I'd like to know what you are talking about and my atlas (Dr. Axelrod) doesn't have S. nummifer.
- smilingSyno
- Posts: 36
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 15:24
- Location 1: Florida, USA
- Interests: Synodontis, Corydoras, Hoplos, Plecos etc.
- Contact:
- gibbo
- Posts: 50
- Joined: 01 Jan 2003, 16:42
- Location 1: Derbyshire, UK
- Interests: Fishkeeping, Photography, Cinema, Crime Literature
Notatus/Nummifer
Crikey, this is making be dizzy!!!
Will be rearranging tank in week so will remove one and photo it comprehensively!!
Will be rearranging tank in week so will remove one and photo it comprehensively!!
- Dinyar
- Posts: 1286
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 00:34
- My articles: 3
- My images: 229
- My catfish: 10
- My cats species list: 3 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 94
- Location 1: New York, NY, USA
- Interests: Mochokidae, Claroteidae, Bagridae, Malepteruridae, Chacidae, Heteropneustidae, Clariidae, Sisoridae, Loricariiadae
Ok, let's try to get a few clear pictures of the head, humeral process and dorsal and adipose fins. If you have a 2.5 gal tank or large specimen container, net the fish into it aand take close-ups in the container. Otherwise, shoot the fish in the net (have someone esle hold it if possible). Don't worry about grasping the fish if you have to. Just don't drop it on the floor!