Page 2 of 3

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 02 Dec 2010, 21:50
by Proteus
Still looking...

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 10 Jul 2011, 20:29
by Deb
Are we still doing this?

On May 11, 2011, 5 Hara jerdoni were added to my 29 US gallon "Indian Almond Leaf" tank. This is my first Asian catfish.

They are very tiny and very sweet! :romance-heartstiny:

Maybe they will spawn but I'm leaving that to them. The tank is set up with Indian almond leaves (Terminalia catappa), dried vines from a local Thai restaurant, willow oak leaves (Quercus phellos) for litter on the bottom, and a variety of Asian plants.

It ran for a year before I added the Hara.

If we're still doing the challenge I'll join in.

Thanks!

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 11 Jul 2011, 00:31
by Proteus
Still have lucked out on locating them whenever Im ordering or in stores.


Right now I might have a better luck when I figure out which shrimps to order, tend to be in the same vendor list as the haras.
but I'm still up for that challenge once I locate em whenever that happens lol


Cheers

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 01 Aug 2011, 06:11
by Deb
lol, Proteus. It seems as if the "Challenge" is in finding them!

Strangely enough, I believe mine have spawned.

I'm getting the pix together now to post.

:d

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 01 Aug 2011, 10:57
by The.Dark.One
Good news. Please post pics of the adults too.

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 01 Aug 2011, 16:59
by Deb
Here is the first pic of the fry, or should I say juvenile.

Image
This young fish is about 11 mm, TL (7 mm, SL.)

All the egg-laying, hatching, and first days of the fry took place unknown to me. This is the only individual I've seen so far, and he is clearly some 7 to 8 weeks old, I'd guess. If there are other juveniles or more fry, they are hiding in the dark recesses of the tank. I do not see all of the fish, even at feeding time.

I'll post more information about the adults and the tank set-up with dates and so forth on a new thread in this forum.

:-BD

Deb

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 02 Aug 2011, 01:12
by Shane
Outstanding accomplishment Deb. Looking forward to more pics and info on the spawning tank set up.
-Shane

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 02 Aug 2011, 04:46
by Deb
Thanks. :ymblushing: When I joined the challenge I didn't imagine for a minute that I would ever see fry, and so soon! It seemed rather impossible.

Now that I've got at least one, it must mean that conditions are favorable, so I've made a chronological account in a separate thread:
Hara jerdoni surprise spawning.
http://www.planetcatfish.com/forum/view ... 05#p225205

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 15 Aug 2011, 00:14
by Proteus
Congrats! :))

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 31 Aug 2011, 21:29
by joefish72b
Congrats on the spawn they are cute little buggers.

Also I have a bunch of them in various sizes, I got a few to put in my 125 sump tank which also doubles as my driftwood sinking tank and there must be about 2 dozen in there now. I never posted any info because it is accidental or incidental spawning (which means I have no idea as to what triggered it).

Here are a couple pics:
Image

Image

Re: The challenge part 2

Posted: 31 Aug 2011, 22:35
by Jools
L number Banana wrote:I'm going to see Iron Maiden
:headbang:

Jools

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 01 Sep 2011, 08:37
by grokefish
Hey I love what you guys have done with my challenge! :-BD

Sow some seeds...........

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 08 Sep 2011, 19:28
by joefish72b
Proteus wrote:Still looking...
Couple questions:
1. Your post date says Dec of 2010, I assume this is a mistake?
2. Do you still need some? I'm willing to part with 6 of my juveniles (check the for sale USA section)

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 08 Sep 2011, 19:44
by MatsP
joefish72b wrote: 1. Your post date says Dec of 2010, I assume this is a mistake?
I'm pretty sure there is no way (other than changing the date/time in the server itself) that one could change the date of the post.

--
Mats

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 08 Sep 2011, 23:05
by joefish72b
MatsP wrote:
joefish72b wrote: 1. Your post date says Dec of 2010, I assume this is a mistake?
I'm pretty sure there is no way (other than changing the date/time in the server itself) that one could change the date of the post.

--
Mats
Sorry Mats, I'm just blind or a little off, never noticed the previous pages were from a year ago.

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 09 Sep 2011, 06:56
by Sam
L number Banana wrote:Nothing yet, had to cancel my Maiden concert for family stuff so won't be in the big city til maybe next week.
Tank is ready though :D
If you mean Iron Maiden then I feel immensely sorry for you count me in belatedly btw thanks (*)

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 20 Sep 2011, 21:10
by Proteus
joefish72b wrote:
Proteus wrote:Still looking...
Couple questions:
1. Your post date says Dec of 2010, I assume this is a mistake?
2. Do you still need some? I'm willing to part with 6 of my juveniles (check the for sale USA section)

point is gone now that they have been bred so quickly :d Plus I'm trying to change up my stocklist right now and getting rid of some fish at this time is proving to be a challenge. Thanks!


Congrats on getting them to spawn so readily.

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 13 Dec 2011, 05:14
by L number Banana
Well, this was hugely successful!!! Awesome! Congrats Deb!! They are adorable!!! :YMAPPLAUSE: :YMAPPLAUSE:


Since the start of this challenge, I missed a concert, took a run on a racetrack, started another tank, lost a few fish but haven't added any new ones.
Could never find the Moth cats :-(

Next challenge is???? Small-ish catfish please :d

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 13 Dec 2011, 20:00
by nvcichlids
I vote on tadpole madtoms.. I have found a fry in my tank, but I want to observe and find out what causes them to breed. They are small enough.

Or maybe Glass cats? (kryp... Minor thingys.)

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 14 Dec 2011, 02:23
by Birger
I think the original rule was...if we actually had rules...that the first of the people taking part who bred that particular fish first got to choose, that was the "prize".

Come up with a new one, we can set up another thread for it.



Birger

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 14 Dec 2011, 10:02
by Jools
The problem with using tadpole madtoms as a subject is that they are either impossible or illegal to keep in many places outside of North America. Now, Glass Cats, however, are a great idea IMHO, but there are lots of other options.

Jools

Re: Breeding Challenge-Moth Cats

Posted: 14 Dec 2011, 11:24
by Shane
Up to the winners, but I agree it should be something fairly easily available, small, and inexpensive.

Some fish that come to mind.






Just some suggestions, there are many possible choices.

-Shane