Page 1 of 1

Help Identifiying Corys

Posted: 18 Mar 2003, 21:06
by Super Coryman
I bought these corys as C.julii. IMHO they are not julii. Any help ???

http://www.aquaworldnet.org/public/gall ... r_Aquarium

Thanks to any replier :D

julli

Posted: 18 Mar 2003, 21:58
by oneoddfish
It's not it's Trilineatus.These are very often sold as julli.

Posted: 19 Mar 2003, 00:04
by Jools
Hmm, wouldn't mind seeing another few pics, that looks like it might be C. leopardus.

Jools

Posted: 19 Mar 2003, 17:32
by Super Coryman
I'll Try posting more pics.

PS Have C. Leopardus been breeded

Posted: 19 Mar 2003, 17:57
by Achim
Hi,

Imo C. leopardus or a closely related species too.
PS Have C. Leopardus been breeded
Yes. According to Hans Evers Corydoras book they have been bred by Ernst Bilke. They are difficult to stimulate, darkening the tank (The method is called "Abdunklungsmethode" in german, i don't know if there is an equivalent in english) finally made them spawn.

Achim

Posted: 19 Mar 2003, 18:59
by Coryman
Without getting a better look at the head I would say the fish was either C. leopardus or possibly C. gomezi. Definately not C. julii
Image
C. leopardus
Image
C. gomezi

Ian

Ps.

Posted: 20 Mar 2003, 21:07
by Super Coryman
Have C. Gomezi ever been bred ??? I'll try posting some more pics when I can.


PS. Ian are you Ian Fuller :?:


Thanks to any repliers

Posted: 20 Mar 2003, 22:19
by Coryman
I'm afraid so

Ian

New Pics !!

Posted: 24 Mar 2003, 20:05
by Super Coryman
Hi
I've uploaded more pics. What do you think ???

http://www.aquaworldnet.org/public/gall ... r_Aquarium
If you can identify them how are they bred???

Posted: 24 Mar 2003, 20:56
by Graeme
C.Leopardus.

(Hope i'm wrong tho!)

Graeme. :D

Posted: 24 Mar 2003, 23:58
by Coryman
I'm still not totally sure that my identification of C. gomezi is correct but I think your fish is the same species. It may turn out to be a new species altogether. Regarding breeding I don't think it has been.

Ian

??

Posted: 25 Mar 2003, 19:19
by Super Coryman
How do you distinguish between C.Trilineatus, C.Gomezi, C.Julii, C.Leopardus ???



What do you think should I try to do to make them breed ???.

Posted: 25 Mar 2003, 20:12
by Coryman
OK the first thing is that C. gomezi and C. leopardus are longnosed species and there are pictires of both on this thred.

C. trilineatus and C. julii have also been covered on Jan 9th and again on March 3rd.
This C. trilineatus / C. julii thing has been bugging me for years. The only way to prove which is which is to know exactly where they were caught.

When viewed head on C. julii are quite slim and not at all stocky looking like C. trilineatus. Exporters in South America use the name C. julii because they get more money for then than they do for C. trilineatus.

Image
True C. julii female,
Image
C. trilineatus
One other point between C. julii and C. trilineatus is that when viewed from the front C. julii are slightly compressed and C. trilineatus are very rounded.

Ian

??

Posted: 29 Mar 2003, 21:35
by Super Coryman
Can someone explain the "Abdunklungsmethode" to me??