Page 1 of 1

Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 04 Mar 2008, 18:34
by worton[pl]
Hey,

what about S. melanostictus and S. nigromaculatus? Both are valid species now as well and melanostictus is endemic to Lake Tanganyika drainage :)

Regards.

Re: Synodontis dhonti

Posted: 04 Mar 2008, 18:45
by Marc van Arc
worton[pl] wrote:what about S. melanostictus and S. nigromaculatus? Both are valid species now as well and melanostictus is endemic to Lake Tanganyika drainage
Hi Worton,
I don't quite understand what you are trying to say. Could you explain your remark pls?

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 04 Mar 2008, 21:57
by MatsP
I split this one from the previous thread on S. dhonti, as it's a separate validation of species names, and Jools needs to do that.

As I understand, Wright & Page, 2006, recognise S. melanostictus as a separate species from S. nigromaculatus - but I'm not 100% sure from my 5 minutes of looking at the subject.

Just to clarify: S. nigromaculatus is in the Cat-eLog, with S. melanostictus as a junior synonym.

--
Mats

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 04 Mar 2008, 22:53
by worton[pl]
Hey,

Mats said it all :)

Regards.

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 05 Mar 2008, 15:32
by Marc van Arc
Ah, okay. I was in fact looking for a link with S. dhonti, but couldn't find it for - by now - obvious reasons.
I'll look into it. Thanks both for the tip and explanation.

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 05 Mar 2008, 17:21
by Jools
OK, let me know if you want a new species entry.

Jools

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 05 Mar 2008, 18:05
by worton[pl]
Hey,

I also should have few photos of syno melanostictus. Well when we took them melanostictus was still a synonym however photos are of a WC fish from Lufubu - probably a melanostictus. I can search for them if you want :).

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 05 Mar 2008, 18:09
by Jools
Now that would be good!

Jools

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 05 Mar 2008, 19:07
by Marc van Arc
Jools wrote:OK, let me know if you want a new species entry.
You can, based on Wright & Page (2006) Synodontis melanostictus is valid.
I'll remove the synonym in S. nigromaculatus.

Re: Synodontis melanostictus vs. S. nigromaculatus

Posted: 08 Mar 2008, 09:44
by Jools
now created!

Jools