Page 1 of 1

Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 20 Feb 2015, 02:25
by bekateen
Hi All,
My LFS has two of these little plecos, each about 3/4 inch long. They were received as "royal plecos" but they don't look like any royal pleco I've ever seen. Can anybody i.d. this pleco? I apologize for the poor photos - my phone isn't the best camera. I'm wondering about plecos like , , , and (actually, I'm really leaning towards L340 because they used to have these in stock as adults. So maybe the supplier is sending the same fish.).
Thank you,
Eric

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 20 Feb 2015, 09:45
by Richard B
certainly NOT royals

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 20 Feb 2015, 18:02
by Marc van Arc
Richard B wrote:certainly NOT royals
Reminds me of a Lorde song ("And we'll never be royals") b-)

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 20 Feb 2015, 21:16
by bekateen
Okay, they aren't royals (that was my thought too). So what are they? L340? (let's see if Lorde can make a song out of L340. LOL)
Cheers, Eric

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 02:05
by racoll
Looks more like than .

The common name for H. debilittera is often "Colombian zebra pleco".

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 03:06
by bekateen
Thanks, Racoll, for the I.d.

Interesting twist: today I was able to speak to the guy who orders for this LFS, and he said the supplier labeled them as mega clown plecos (the misidentification as a royal pleco was made by another employee who is relatively new at the store). These are about 3/4 inch long and their wholesale price is $25USD. Around this area of California, retailers tend to have a 3x markup on their livestock. But there's no way my LFS can expect to sell these for $75USD, so they're priced at $30USD, which still seems high to me, even for a mega clown pleco.

If these are debilittera, is that a good price? And how can I definitively tell debilittera apart from L340?

Thanks, Eric

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 03:32
by racoll
how can I definitively tell debilittera apart from L340?
Probably the same species, but the L340 seems to have a longer snout, smaller eyes, and a more yellowish colour. Take a look at the cat-elog pictures, and you can see there is nothing definitive there, but some look pretty different.

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 04:08
by bekateen
Okay, thanks. Yes I did take a look at the photos. Alas, I've never seen either type alive and in person. I'll do my best.
Cheers, Eric

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 05:05
by bekateen
For people who know the US market, does $30USD seem excessive for either of these plecos (debilittera or L340)?

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 12:01
by cjp155
I personally wouldn't pay more than $20 for L129. I have seen them for as low as $10. I am not familiar with L340 pricing.

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 12:10
by Atmichaels
Eric-in the U.S., you can usually find debiliterra marketed at $20-$25 each and frequently see them 3 for $45 online. Same for L340's.

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 13:55
by bekateen
Thanks to both of you. Yes, I thought the price seemed high.

Cheers, Eric

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 21 Feb 2015, 22:24
by TwoTankAmin
Most folks wont sell them at that size. They should be at least 1.5 inches TL, imo.

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 22 Feb 2015, 01:02
by Coldhands
If these are debilittera, is that a good price?
These typically sell here for $19.99.

Re: Being sold as royal plecos - doesn't look right

Posted: 22 Feb 2015, 07:38
by bekateen
Thank you both. Yes, they seem to be both overpriced and undersized. TTA, believe it or not, these aren't the smallest plecos I've found in a LFS. Last Autumn I visited a LFS in the Sierra Nevada mountains. It seemed like a really good store until I saw them selling normal (not albino) common BNs less than 1cm long as "microplecos." I was offended by this because I suspect most people who buy these won't this be able to keep them alive. BNs are tough, but babies are still fragile.