Lets start with the basics - what's your water quality:
nitrate (NO3), nitrite(NO2), ammonia(NH3/NH4)?
NH3/4: 0
NO2: 0
NO3: about 10ppm, give or take 2ppm. (Test kit scale is a little harder to read at the lower levels)
What's the temperature?
84 degrees Fahrenheit. I'm treating ich right ...