My new cat from Papua New Guinea
- The.Dark.One
- Posts: 1504
- Joined: 03 Feb 2003, 20:24
- I've donated: $26.00!
- My articles: 1
- My images: 20
- My cats species list: 41 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 16
- Location 1: Castleford, West Yorkshire, England
- Location 2: Castleford
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
This is from the New Guinea shipment Pier Aquatics had in, along with Plotosus papuensis, Neosilurus brevidorsalis, N. equinus. Can't decide between N. ater or N. novaguineae. What do you guys think? The fish is about 20 inches.
- Jools
- Expert
- Posts: 15993
- Joined: 30 Dec 2002, 15:25
- My articles: 197
- My images: 944
- My catfish: 238
- My cats species list: 87 (i:13, k:1)
- My BLogs: 7 (i:7, p:202)
- My Wishlist: 23
- Spotted: 447
- Location 1: Middle Earth,
- Location 2: Scotland
- Interests: All things aquatic, Sci-Fi, photography and travel. Oh, and beer.
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Looks dissimilar to my N. ater. Aside from the fact my fish is black, it also has the much more of the back sprouting a fin.
Jools
Jools
Owner, AquaticRepublic.com, PlanetCatfish.com & ZebraPleco.com. Please consider donating towards this site's running costs.
- The.Dark.One
- Posts: 1504
- Joined: 03 Feb 2003, 20:24
- I've donated: $26.00!
- My articles: 1
- My images: 20
- My cats species list: 41 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 16
- Location 1: Castleford, West Yorkshire, England
- Location 2: Castleford
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Going on the drawings in Freshwater Fishes of New Guinea N. ater and N. novaguineae both have the second dorsal starting quite far back on the body (as does N. ater in Field Guide to Freshwater Fishes of Australia) In the books N ater also has the high dorsal and the ventral fins quite close to the long pecs, so it seems to match N. ater in the books, but not N. ater in other photographs, that's why I went for N. novaguineae, but the first dorsal and pecs and ventrals seem to match the N ater in the books, so I'm a but puzzled.
- snowball
- Posts: 332
- Joined: 31 Jul 2005, 11:41
- I've donated: $40.00!
- My cats species list: 47 (i:23, k:0)
- My aquaria list: 5 (i:5)
- My BLogs: 1 (i:0, p:16)
- My Wishlist: 4
- Spotted: 28
- Location 1: Sydney
- Location 2: Australia
- Interests: Plotosidae
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
I don't think the first or third pics on the previous page are N. ater. The body is not tall enough nor is the snout as angular as in N. ater.
N. brevidorsalis is a more likely choice for the second but that is just a quick guess.
I have a couple of books on NG fish which list quite a few of the cats but they are in storage in the attic and it will take a few days to dig them out.
N. brevidorsalis is a more likely choice for the second but that is just a quick guess.
I have a couple of books on NG fish which list quite a few of the cats but they are in storage in the attic and it will take a few days to dig them out.
- snowball
- Posts: 332
- Joined: 31 Jul 2005, 11:41
- I've donated: $40.00!
- My cats species list: 47 (i:23, k:0)
- My aquaria list: 5 (i:5)
- My BLogs: 1 (i:0, p:16)
- My Wishlist: 4
- Spotted: 28
- Location 1: Sydney
- Location 2: Australia
- Interests: Plotosidae
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Photo 1 I am not sure what it is. The closest plotosidae in appearance is Tandanus bostoki. The colour is similar as is the mouth shape and the secondary dorsal appears to carry further along the body as in Tandanus. Based on this I don't think it is a Neosilurus species. However T. bostocki is recorded (afaik) only in the south west of West Austrlia. Perhaps it is also found in New Guinea, or perhaps this is a different species of Tandanus? Or it might be a different genus altogether. If would be great if you can find out what river it was collected from.
Photo 2 does look like P. papuensis.
Photo 3 I think is Neosilurus mollespiculum. The dorsal & pectoral ray counts appear to match up as does the colouration description. I am sure it is not N. ater as I have seen many of them and they all have a different head shape, although the eyes are similar. Again my references only show this is as Australian (North Qld) but it is from a regional focused book so you never know where else it may turn up.
The Dark One: Your cat looks more like Oloplotosus mariae, however that is only known from a single species collected in the upper Fly-Strickland. But you never know, you may be lucky! Let me know if you want the ray counts.
Photo 2 does look like P. papuensis.
Photo 3 I think is Neosilurus mollespiculum. The dorsal & pectoral ray counts appear to match up as does the colouration description. I am sure it is not N. ater as I have seen many of them and they all have a different head shape, although the eyes are similar. Again my references only show this is as Australian (North Qld) but it is from a regional focused book so you never know where else it may turn up.
The Dark One: Your cat looks more like Oloplotosus mariae, however that is only known from a single species collected in the upper Fly-Strickland. But you never know, you may be lucky! Let me know if you want the ray counts.
- Silurus
- Posts: 12378
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 11:35
- I've donated: $12.00!
- My articles: 55
- My images: 884
- My catfish: 1
- My cats species list: 90 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 419
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Moderator Emeritus
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Wrong. Steve's fish looks nothing like .The Dark One: Your cat looks more like Oloplotosus mariae, however that is only known from a single species collected in the upper Fly-Strickland. But you never know, you may be lucky! Let me know if you want the ray counts.
- snowball
- Posts: 332
- Joined: 31 Jul 2005, 11:41
- I've donated: $40.00!
- My cats species list: 47 (i:23, k:0)
- My aquaria list: 5 (i:5)
- My BLogs: 1 (i:0, p:16)
- My Wishlist: 4
- Spotted: 28
- Location 1: Sydney
- Location 2: Australia
- Interests: Plotosidae
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
My error then as I didn't check what was already in the catelog. I compared it against a photo of a dead fish that does resemble Steve's fish more closely than the catelog pics.
Do you think it is a Plotosus species or something else?
Do you think it is a Plotosus species or something else?
- Jools
- Expert
- Posts: 15993
- Joined: 30 Dec 2002, 15:25
- My articles: 197
- My images: 944
- My catfish: 238
- My cats species list: 87 (i:13, k:1)
- My BLogs: 7 (i:7, p:202)
- My Wishlist: 23
- Spotted: 447
- Location 1: Middle Earth,
- Location 2: Scotland
- Interests: All things aquatic, Sci-Fi, photography and travel. Oh, and beer.
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
So, I think this:
Does the attached key help?
Jools
and the pic of Steve's above as an attachment are the same thing. I think the initial consensus is with a lot of doubt.amiidae wrote:
Does the attached key help?
Jools
Owner, AquaticRepublic.com, PlanetCatfish.com & ZebraPleco.com. Please consider donating towards this site's running costs.
- The.Dark.One
- Posts: 1504
- Joined: 03 Feb 2003, 20:24
- I've donated: $26.00!
- My articles: 1
- My images: 20
- My cats species list: 41 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 16
- Location 1: Castleford, West Yorkshire, England
- Location 2: Castleford
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Not much as we can't count gill rakers from these photos but IMO the position of the second dorsal, the relative placement of the ventral fins and the golden colour lean towards N. ater. And I settled on N. ater for my pic too.
- Jools
- Expert
- Posts: 15993
- Joined: 30 Dec 2002, 15:25
- My articles: 197
- My images: 944
- My catfish: 238
- My cats species list: 87 (i:13, k:1)
- My BLogs: 7 (i:7, p:202)
- My Wishlist: 23
- Spotted: 447
- Location 1: Middle Earth,
- Location 2: Scotland
- Interests: All things aquatic, Sci-Fi, photography and travel. Oh, and beer.
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
I think the golden colour should be discounted. There's a good chance many of these species do this.
However, could we not say, if the number of gill rakers is 20 then it is species A (due to character B) and if it's less than 13 then it is species C becuase of character(s) D.
I am interested in what you think B and D is.
Jools
However, could we not say, if the number of gill rakers is 20 then it is species A (due to character B) and if it's less than 13 then it is species C becuase of character(s) D.
I am interested in what you think B and D is.
Jools
Owner, AquaticRepublic.com, PlanetCatfish.com & ZebraPleco.com. Please consider donating towards this site's running costs.
- The.Dark.One
- Posts: 1504
- Joined: 03 Feb 2003, 20:24
- I've donated: $26.00!
- My articles: 1
- My images: 20
- My cats species list: 41 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 16
- Location 1: Castleford, West Yorkshire, England
- Location 2: Castleford
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
I'm not so sure the golden colour should be discounted. It has only been noted in one population of N. ater and if it was present in other species I would have thought it would have cropped up in the studies done by Australian and New Guinea ichthyologists, although I suppose it depends on how much they have been studied.
Let me check my books when I get home and see if I've another key. Which book is that key out of?
Let me check my books when I get home and see if I've another key. Which book is that key out of?
- Jools
- Expert
- Posts: 15993
- Joined: 30 Dec 2002, 15:25
- My articles: 197
- My images: 944
- My catfish: 238
- My cats species list: 87 (i:13, k:1)
- My BLogs: 7 (i:7, p:202)
- My Wishlist: 23
- Spotted: 447
- Location 1: Middle Earth,
- Location 2: Scotland
- Interests: All things aquatic, Sci-Fi, photography and travel. Oh, and beer.
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
The fishes of the Indo-Australian Archipelago Vol II, Weber & Beaufort 1913.The.Dark.One wrote:Which book is that key out of?
Jools
Owner, AquaticRepublic.com, PlanetCatfish.com & ZebraPleco.com. Please consider donating towards this site's running costs.
- The.Dark.One
- Posts: 1504
- Joined: 03 Feb 2003, 20:24
- I've donated: $26.00!
- My articles: 1
- My images: 20
- My cats species list: 41 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 16
- Location 1: Castleford, West Yorkshire, England
- Location 2: Castleford
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Ah yes, I have that (twice!).
Well meraukensis is a Porochilus now anyway, bartoni and perugiae are synonyms of brevidorsalis.
I have a more up to date key of the Australian ones (though that is from 1989) and one for the New Guinea ones (1991).
Some species overlap and are found in both islands. It will be easy to just reproduce the keys as they are but they may only be useful if the owner knows the origin of the fish. I could try and merge the two and come up with one but I can't vouch for its accuracy!
Well meraukensis is a Porochilus now anyway, bartoni and perugiae are synonyms of brevidorsalis.
I have a more up to date key of the Australian ones (though that is from 1989) and one for the New Guinea ones (1991).
Some species overlap and are found in both islands. It will be easy to just reproduce the keys as they are but they may only be useful if the owner knows the origin of the fish. I could try and merge the two and come up with one but I can't vouch for its accuracy!
-
- Posts: 145
- Joined: 01 Dec 2010, 14:32
- My images: 34
- My cats species list: 7 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 15
- Location 2: Singapore
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Picked up one today as well , any guesses for the I.D ? It has since developed a slight mottled pattern upon settling down as well as a more yellowish colour.
- The.Dark.One
- Posts: 1504
- Joined: 03 Feb 2003, 20:24
- I've donated: $26.00!
- My articles: 1
- My images: 20
- My cats species list: 41 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 16
- Location 1: Castleford, West Yorkshire, England
- Location 2: Castleford
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
At first glance, N. brevidorsalis
- amiidae
- Posts: 597
- Joined: 25 Nov 2004, 13:19
- My images: 546
- My cats species list: 82 (i:0, k:2)
- Spotted: 178
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Singapore
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
1)
2)
3)
The above are diff specimen. All same species ?
2)
3)
The above are diff specimen. All same species ?
PREDATORY FISH KEEPERS FB GROUP --> https://www.facebook.com/groups/166535030633179/
- Silurus
- Posts: 12378
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 11:35
- I've donated: $12.00!
- My articles: 55
- My images: 884
- My catfish: 1
- My cats species list: 90 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 419
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Moderator Emeritus
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Are they the same size?
- amiidae
- Posts: 597
- Joined: 25 Nov 2004, 13:19
- My images: 546
- My cats species list: 82 (i:0, k:2)
- Spotted: 178
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Singapore
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
If I remember correctly.
Fish 1 : abt 19inches TL.
Fish 2 : abt 16-17 inches TL.
Fishes 3 : 15 inches TL.
Was told they were fm Papua Indonesia.
Fish 1 : abt 19inches TL.
Fish 2 : abt 16-17 inches TL.
Fishes 3 : 15 inches TL.
Was told they were fm Papua Indonesia.
PREDATORY FISH KEEPERS FB GROUP --> https://www.facebook.com/groups/166535030633179/
- Silurus
- Posts: 12378
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 11:35
- I've donated: $12.00!
- My articles: 55
- My images: 884
- My catfish: 1
- My cats species list: 90 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 419
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Moderator Emeritus
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Those sizes rule out quite a number of New Guinean Neosilurus. However, I cannot find the distinctive features of any other large Neosilurus from New Guinea, so I am forced to conclude they are all the same species.
- amiidae
- Posts: 597
- Joined: 25 Nov 2004, 13:19
- My images: 546
- My cats species list: 82 (i:0, k:2)
- Spotted: 178
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Singapore
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Thanks, HH.
So can we rule out N ater ?
So can we rule out N ater ?
PREDATORY FISH KEEPERS FB GROUP --> https://www.facebook.com/groups/166535030633179/
- Silurus
- Posts: 12378
- Joined: 31 Dec 2002, 11:35
- I've donated: $12.00!
- My articles: 55
- My images: 884
- My catfish: 1
- My cats species list: 90 (i:0, k:0)
- Spotted: 419
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Moderator Emeritus
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
We can rule out most species except N. ater.
- amiidae
- Posts: 597
- Joined: 25 Nov 2004, 13:19
- My images: 546
- My cats species list: 82 (i:0, k:2)
- Spotted: 178
- Location 1: Singapore
- Location 2: Singapore
- Contact:
Re: My new cat from Papua New Guinea
Neosilurus mollespiculum. Quite close as compared to that yellow N. ater.
https://fishesofaustralia.net.au/home/species/3307
https://fishesofaustralia.net.au/home/species/3307
PREDATORY FISH KEEPERS FB GROUP --> https://www.facebook.com/groups/166535030633179/